Mark Salling (better known to Gleeks as Puck) sent many female hearts fluttering when he sweetly crooned “Sweet Caroline” to Rachel Berry (Lea Michele) and caused many an eye to tear when he sang “Beth” to Quinn Fabray (Dianna Agron).

Tonight, he’ll offer up plenty of potent sex appeal to all the ladies - and we’ve got the video to prove it.

The Glee star will attack Billy Joel’s “Only the Good Die Young” in the show’s upcoming “Grilled Cheesus” episode, which delves into the heady subject matter of organized religion (yikes). Thankfully, there will be plenty of jam to sweeten the pill; between Finn’s quips (delivered so well by Cory Monteith) and Puck’s singing, Tuesday may well feel a bit like a religious experience.

Puck’s solos are beginning to take on a theme, and it seems he’ll continue in the same vein. “At this time I’d like to continue my streak of doing only songs by Jewish artists,” he explains before presenting the song.

Time to start putting together those request lists!