I am debating between buying these two things:

http://www.walmart.com/catalog/product.gsp?product_id=3340268&cat=41937&type=19&dept=3944&path=0%3A3944%3A3951%3A41937

or

http://www.walmart.com/catalog/product.gsp?product_id=3377723

which would you choose? hard decision :think:

those mp3 players are huge, i would go for the pc 😉

their huge? is that good? bad?

DEFINITELY the pc. For one thing,that’s nowhere near the best price for the creative 5gb zen micro.

For another thing,the 5gb zen doesn’t do NEARLY enough to be worth even $210, compared to all the other awesome mp3 players out now for less money.

Go for an iriver,or a 20gb zen touch. Maybe even a Archos mp3/video player if you’re feeling good.

I just personally bought a brand new Archos Gmini 400 from amazon.com a couple days ago. This thing is absolutely amazing. I’ve had it for 2 days now,& so far,I’ve got no complaints. I put a pda screen protector on it to keep it safe from scratches. Amazon lists it for only $336.00 .

Here’s a link for all the stats on the Gmini.It says “Games on tv” ,but that means games can be played on the Gmini AND on a tv. Anyway,here’s the info:

P.S. The size of the Gmini is even smaller than the 20Gb Ipod. The Gmini is almost the same length as a closed Motorola v400 phone.  :D This site has a long article with wonderful pictures & ratings on the Gmini 400:  

i kind of wanted the zen for the reason of the replacable battery, for like so i could use the player for more than a year w.o it dying out on me….. hmmmmm

PC those Zen’s are ugly!  Oh and the iPod battery lasts over a year, what matters is the # of charges.  Mine is still going fine, it’s 3 years old.

actually there really cool lookin

maybe the crative zen touch?

if you guys dont like these creatives wats the best 20 gig mp3 player for $220.00 or under?