< 1 2
2 of 2
PSP Or DS which are you getting?
Posted: 07 October 2004 01:02 PM   [ # 26 ]     [ Ignore ]   [ # 26 ]  
I'm A Regular
Total Posts:  855
Joined  2004-09-27

[quote author=“chillywilly”]PSP…

My daughter will end up with the DS, but she’s more Nintendo than I am.  I’ve been PlayStation since 1995.  Currently have a PS2.

Agree with that Sony all the way!

Profile
 
Posted: 07 October 2004 04:34 PM   [ # 27 ]     [ Ignore ]   [ # 27 ]  
I'm A Regular
Total Posts:  855
Joined  2004-09-27
[quote author=“Bootes”]I would love many of the extra features of the PSP, but Sony has to be Stupid and try and creat a new format every time they release a product.  I’ll probably get a DS if I have to pay.  If I can get them for free I’ll get both 😊

Hmm… lets think about that.
NINTENDO                  /              SONY

Nintendo’s:Cartridges               /              Sony PS1:Discs

N64:Cartridges                     /              Sony PS2: Discs/DVD              

Gameboy’s:Cartridges             /              Sony PSP: Mini Discs

Gamecube: Discs

DS:Not sure, probably not cartriges                

Seems pretty even to me…

Profile
 
Posted: 09 October 2004 03:22 PM   [ # 28 ]     [ Ignore ]   [ # 28 ]  
Initiation
Total Posts:  37
Joined  2004-08-26

Originally I was going to go with the PSP, but lately I’ve been swaying towards the DS.  Why?  Well I personally think that it’s going to have a lot of interesting games, such as this:

http://www.the-magicbox.com/0410/game041008g.shtml

Using the dual screen and touch sensitive stylus, you operate on patients on the screen.  Of course, one game isn’t expected to sway many opinions, but I think that innovation like this is fodder for better and more imaginative games to come.

The combination of the dual screen and touch sensitivity is great, but the wireless is also something to behold.  Granted PSP has this too, but Nintendo’s plans for it are far more ambitious.  They are toying with the idea of being able to transmit game demos in stores via wireless to play for a limited time to help propagate a wider breadth of games rather than just sequels.  In association with (you knew it was coming) Pokemon, they are experimenting with the thought of transmitting unique pokemon info in theatres during the upcoming Pokemon movies to be broadcasted onto the DSs.

Also, the fact that the Nintendo DS is backwards compatible with the thousands of Gameboy and Gameboy Advance games doesn’t hurt.

Nintendo is also revising its portable strategy; they made a clear distinction that their GBA is meant to target young-teen audiences, while the DS caters to the older generation.  Announced games like Final Fantasy 3 remake(!), Ridge Racer DS, and Metroid: Hunters attest to this.  However, some things just quite never change—and for Nintendo, it may be a good thing.  There will always be a wide library of “kiddy” games making the DS all the more accessible to all, and their tried and true tradition of affordability (DS will debut at $149, games at $29).

The PSP looks like a great peripheral, but it has a few flaws that come to mind.  The first is price.  If Sony wants to get competetive, they can’t stick with that horrendous speculated price of ~$250-350.  This will not only make it inaccessible but downright unappealing.

The second is battery life.  Even Nintendo made a crack at Sony, making a solid statement of the DS’ battery life (around 10 hours), while Sony still prefers to keep it hush hush.  Case and point?  The PSP girls at E3 who were walking around letting people play the PSP demos had to recharge it every two hours.

The third is reliability.  Now, I’m not doubting Sony from the get-go but we all know how faulty PS2s are.  Many have been vexxed by their disc read errors, overheating, and whatnot (Sony has even lost a class action lawsuit due to the unreliability of the PS2), so for Sony to venture into an area that they have never been before is a little troubling to the mind.  Still, I’ll reserve judgment until the final product arrives.

Those are my 2 cents on the issue.  DS, for me, wins this round for now.

Profile
 
Posted: 09 October 2004 04:59 PM   [ # 29 ]     [ Ignore ]   [ # 29 ]  
I'm A Regular
Total Posts:  711
Joined  2005-01-03

Dissolution, I mean for the extra features.  I’m not gonna buy a movie that I can only play on the PSP,  I should be able to put my own movies onto it.  Then we have Sony’s Audio format, they sell Music Players that can only play there own format, no MP’s.  Mini Disc players, they tried to get these to replace CD’s.

Profile
 
Posted: 17 October 2004 04:13 PM   [ # 30 ]     [ Ignore ]   [ # 30 ]  
Initiation
Total Posts:  36
Joined  2005-02-22

[quote author=“ViS6pt7”]Originally I was going to go with the PSP, but lately I’ve been swaying towards the DS.  Why?  Well I personally think that it’s going to have a lot of interesting games, such as this:

http://www.the-magicbox.com/0410/game041008g.shtml

Using the dual screen and touch sensitive stylus, you operate on patients on the screen.  Of course, one game isn’t expected to sway many opinions, but I think that innovation like this is fodder for better and more imaginative games to come.

The combination of the dual screen and touch sensitivity is great, but the wireless is also something to behold.  Granted PSP has this too, but Nintendo’s plans for it are far more ambitious.  They are toying with the idea of being able to transmit game demos in stores via wireless to play for a limited time to help propagate a wider breadth of games rather than just sequels.  In association with (you knew it was coming) Pokemon, they are experimenting with the thought of transmitting unique pokemon info in theatres during the upcoming Pokemon movies to be broadcasted onto the DSs.

Also, the fact that the Nintendo DS is backwards compatible with the thousands of Gameboy and Gameboy Advance games doesn’t hurt.

Nintendo is also revising its portable strategy; they made a clear distinction that their GBA is meant to target young-teen audiences, while the DS caters to the older generation.  Announced games like Final Fantasy 3 remake(!), Ridge Racer DS, and Metroid: Hunters attest to this.  However, some things just quite never change—and for Nintendo, it may be a good thing.  There will always be a wide library of “kiddy” games making the DS all the more accessible to all, and their tried and true tradition of affordability (DS will debut at $149, games at $29).

The PSP looks like a great peripheral, but it has a few flaws that come to mind.  The first is price.  If Sony wants to get competetive, they can’t stick with that horrendous speculated price of ~$250-350.  This will not only make it inaccessible but downright unappealing.

The second is battery life.  Even Nintendo made a crack at Sony, making a solid statement of the DS’ battery life (around 10 hours), while Sony still prefers to keep it hush hush.  Case and point?  The PSP girls at E3 who were walking around letting people play the PSP demos had to recharge it every two hours.

The third is reliability.  Now, I’m not doubting Sony from the get-go but we all know how faulty PS2s are.  Many have been vexxed by their disc read errors, overheating, and whatnot (Sony has even lost a class action lawsuit due to the unreliability of the PS2), so for Sony to venture into an area that they have never been before is a little troubling to the mind.  Still, I’ll reserve judgment until the final product arrives.

Those are my 2 cents on the issue.  DS, for me, wins this round for now.

 

well, sorry to tell u guys, the ds will not be backwards compatible wiht gameboy games, just advance. Nintendo found it too costly to add the chip.

Aslo, yea, the psp will have crappy battery life, disks are so much worse than cartriges in terms of relaibily and the psp will have to use memory sticks wheras nintendo is built onto the cartrige.
Im so getting a DS

Profile
 
Posted: 18 October 2004 08:55 AM   [ # 31 ]     [ Ignore ]   [ # 31 ]  
I'm A Regular
Total Posts:  711
Joined  2005-01-03

Plus MP on DS only one person needs the game. :D PSP everyone needs the game :(

Profile
 
Posted: 18 October 2004 12:45 PM   [ # 32 ]     [ Ignore ]   [ # 32 ]  
Initiation
Total Posts:  36
Joined  2005-02-22

yea, only one person needs the game in a room of 16 people (the max in a game)

Profile
 
Posted: 18 October 2004 01:27 PM   [ # 33 ]     [ Ignore ]   [ # 33 ]  
In The Club
Total Posts:  211
Joined  2004-12-28

I think i’ll be getting the PSP even though ive heard that they are not going to be using an analog stick.

Profile
 
 < 1 2
2 of 2
‹‹ MY CAMERA!      Video iPod in November? ››