What could possibly be worse than finding out that your boyfriend cheated on you? Finding out that he’s considered People‘s Hottest Bachelor! (Sorry, Karina.)

While I’m certain the magazine selected Mario Lopez long before tales of cheating ways were revealed (that’s if you don’t count Ali Landry’s experience), his inclusion just goes to show that any guy with a dimple can come off as charming.

In his interview with People, the Broadway star explained what he looks for in a woman. “I like a girl who’s from a modest sort of upbringing, because it’s more relatable.”

Funny. Maybe it’s just me, but I’ve never once equated the words Hooters and modesty before.